Analogous Unity in the Writings of John Duns Scotus
Schöpfer:
D'ettore, Domenic
Related Url Tesim:
Access available from the library catalog: https://marianunivindianapolis.on.worldcat.org/oclc/9639820114 and Access available from the publisher: https://muse.jhu.edu/article/866589
Beschreibung:
Aristotle identifies four modes of unity: numerical, specific, generic, and proportional or analogous. Recent scholarship has renewed the Renaissance and early Modern Thomist critique that John Duns Scotus's (d. 1308) doctrine of the univocity of being is based on a failure to appreciate proportional unity. This paper attempts to fill a gap in the copious literature on Scotus's doctrine of the univocity of being by presenting and offering an analysis of the texts where Scotus addresses the topic of proportional or analogous unity. The paper argues that Scotus's early and mature works consistently reject the notion that an analogous or proportional unity can serve as the foundation for greater than equivocal unity between concepts, and that Scotus's developed position represents an alternative to Aristotle's division of unity into the modes of numerical, specific, generic, and analogous. Nonetheless, Scotus's early remarks on an analogous unity that is mind-independent provide both an internal justification for the dispute that ensues between Thomists and Scotists over whether a single concept can signify analogously—a dispute that features such distinguished participants as Thomas de Vio Cajetan (1469–1534) and Bartolomaeus Mastrius (1602–73)—and an avenue for further investigation into the thought of the Subtle Doctor.
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Sprache:
English
Herausgeber:
Johns Hopkins University Press
Ressourcentyp:
Article
Stichwort:
analogous unity, Thomism, Aristotle, univocity of being, analogy, Scotism, and John Duns Scotus
At the beginning of his influential De Nominum Analogia, Thomas de Vio Cajetan (1469–1534) mentions three mistaken positions on analogy. He does not attach names to these positions, but each one was held by distinguished Thomists of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. Furthermore, their proponents were responding to the same set of challenges from John Duns Scotus that set the agenda for the De Nominum Analogia. In this paper, I would like to do something that Cajetan did not do, and that is, directly consider the merits of the first position in his list of mistaken accounts of analogy; namely, the position that analogy is constituted by (in)disjunction. More specifically, this paper investigates the polemical use for which Hervaeus Natalis (1260–1323) deployed analogy of disjunction; the reply of John Duns Scotus; and the implications of this back and forth for understanding the Thomist-Scotist dispute over the concept of being.
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Sprache:
English
Identifikator:
https://doi.org/10.5840/studneoar20201711
Ressourcentyp:
Article
Stichwort:
analogy of being, Hervaeus Natalis, and John Duns Scotus
Christian Discipleship: The Primordial Model for Comprehensive Catholic Youth Ministry
Schöpfer:
Canales, Art
Beschreibung:
This article addresses Christian discipleship: (1) as a primordial model for comprehensive Catholic youth ministry and (2) as a developmental theology for contemporary youth ministry. Moreover, it situates Christian discipleship in Catholic youth ministry and offers a systematic, intentional, and pragmatic approach for ministering to adolescents. Furthermore, the study offers 8 theological categories for integration into and enrichment for a Christian discipleship model of youth ministry. Finally, the essay provides 6 pedagogical and practical strategies for Catholic youth ministers to implement into their curriculum, and a praxis-oriented approach that Catholic practitioners will appreciate.
Christology for Youth & Young Adults: Biblical, Historical, Liturgical, and Pastoral Perspectives
Schöpfer:
Canales, Arthur D.
Related Url Tesim:
Available from the publisher: https://he.kendallhunt.com/product/christology-youth-and-young-adults-biblical-historical-liturgical-and-pastoral-perspectives and Available from the library catalog: https://marianunivindianapolis.on.worldcat.org/oclc/1393300655
Beschreibung:
Christology for Youth & Young Adults: Biblical, Historical, Liturgical, and Pastoral Perspectives provides readers with solid post-Vatican II Catholic theology as well as contemporary Christian theology. As Canales states several times throughout the book, "Christology is the heart and soul of all Christian theology," as he captures this reality by offering a variety of perspectives to expand our Christian horizons of Christology. One of the main goals of the book is to offer new ways of thinking about certain topics surrounding Jesus's life and ministry.
The book examines biblical, historical, liturgical, and pastoral perspectives and offers new insights and fresh ideas to readers by addressing these various themes. The book is ecumenical, informative, and practical; suitable for the classroom and ministry settings. The book also provides readers with the author's own introspection on some o fthe pastoral perspectives. Some of the book's topics include the titles and images for Jesus, the parables of Jesus, the micacles of Jesus, the cosmic Christ, and many more.
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Sprache:
English
Herausgeber:
Kendall Hunt Publishing Company
Identifikator:
ISBN: 9798385101740 and ISBN: 9798385101757
Ressourcentyp:
Book
Stichwort:
Post-Vatican II Catholic theology, contemporary Christian theology, and Christology
De Novo Evaluation of Gender Dysphoria Misconceptions and Islamic Religious Perplexity: Is there any Chance of Reconciliation?
Schöpfer:
Taslim, N. and Canales, Arthur D.
Related Url Tesim:
Available from the publisher: https://al-kindipublisher.com/index.php/jgcs/article/view/4933
Beschreibung:
Gender dysphoria [GD] or a sex and gender discord that leads to enormous psychological suffering in some variants of transgender people is a highly complex and debatable subject. Muslim culture, religious and ethical values pose more challenges to the acceptance of GD than the Western system. The purpose of this narrative review is to present and discuss GD misconceptions and contrasting Islamic views with a fresh perspective and a rational approach in light of current advancements in this field. Since there are no directives in the Holy Quran and Hadith on matters of GD, Muslims have been polarized regarding GD. The so-called “liberal scholars” corroborate the scientific fact and view GD patients as a medical condition, which necessitates contemporary therapeutic interventions. Conversely, the so-called “conservative approaches” regard GD a delusional thinking probably arising from a mental illness, or a spiritual immorality, which necessitates psychotherapy or zealous religious guidance. Due to the religious tensions, generalized unawareness, and scarcity of the quality multifaceted research, there is widespread misconceptions and hostility toward transgender people in Islamic culture. The critical appraisal of the Islamic debate on GD proves that despite its ambiguity and intricacies, GD remains a stark reality and merits resolution. Though conflicted on GD, Islamic jurists concur that Islamic laws founded on core principles of love, and respect for all dictate rational reasoning, and enlightened approach on obscure matters. Young Muslims can help reconcile GD conflict in Islamic societies by initiating intra-faith dialogues and engaging their religious scholars in clinical and patient-centered research to broaden their perspective. Collaborative efforts can prompt conservative Islamic scholars to re-negotiate their antagonistic stance on GD or SRT. Islamic leaders can also influence local governments and policy makers to develop policies to improve the welfare of long-ignored transgender people that deserve attention, empathy, and treatment on moral and religious grounds.
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Lizenz:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Sprache:
English
Herausgeber:
Al-Kindi Center for Research and Development
Identifikator:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.32996/jgcs.2023.3.1.2
Ressourcentyp:
Article
Stichwort:
Gender dysphoria [GD], Islam, Muslims, Religious controversy, and Muslim countries
Available for access from the library catalog: https://marianunivindianapolis.on.worldcat.org/oclc/1220972854 and Available from the publisher: https://www.fortresspress.com/store/product/9780800663759/Documents-and-Images-for-the-Study-of-Paul
Beschreibung:
The world surrounding Paul and the assemblies comes vividly to life here. Documents and Images for the Study of Paul gathers representative texts illustrating Jewish practices, Greco-Roman moral exhortation, biblical interpretation, Roman ideology, apocalyptic visions, epistolary conventions, and more to illustrate the complex cultural environment in which Paul carried out his apostolic work#and the manifold ways in which his legacy was reshaped in early Christianity. Paul is the focus of intense and often controversial scholarly attention today. Brief, insightful introductions orient the reader to the significance of ancient sources for different contemporary interpretations of Paul's life and thought. Photographs illustrate the visual environment of the Greco-Roman world; a map, a timeline, and an index of scripture passages make the sourcebook the perfect companion text for studying Paul and his letters. This is a foundational work for everyone who wants to learn more about Paul and the cultural, political, and religious environment of the Apostle's work and his letters - Publisher description.
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Sprache:
English
Herausgeber:
Fortress Press
Identifikator:
ISBN: 1451415141 and ISBN: 9781451415148
Ressourcentyp:
Book
Stichwort:
Early Christianity, Paul of Tarsus, Ancient sources, Greco-Roman world, and Biblical interpretation
Dominic of Flanders’ Critique of John Duns Scotus’ Primary Argument for the University of Being
Schöpfer:
D'Ettore, Domenic
Related Url Tesim:
Originally published in Vivarium (Vol.56, Iss.1-2) at: https://brill.com/abstract/journals/viv/56/1-2/article-p176_176.xml
Beschreibung:
This article considers the attempt by a prominent fifteenth-century follower of Thomas Aquinas, Dominic of Flanders (a.k.a. Flandrensis, 1425-1479), to address John Duns Scotus’ most famous argument for the univocity of being. According to Scotus, the intellect must have a concept of being that is univocal to substantial and accidental being, and to finite and infinite being, on the grounds that an intellect cannot be both certain and doubtful through the same concept, but an intellect can be certain that something is a being while doubting whether it is a substance or accident, finite or infinite. The article shows how Flandrensis’ reply in defence of analogy of being hinges on a more fundamental disagreement with Scotus over the division of the logically one. It also shows how Flandrensis’ answer to this question commits him to a position on the unity of the concept of being that lies between the positions of Scotus and of Flandrensis’ earlier Thomistic sources.
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Sprache:
English
Herausgeber:
Brill
Identifikator:
https://doi.org/10.1163/15685349-12341352
Ressourcentyp:
Article
Stichwort:
Thomas Aquinas, Dominic of Flanders, John Duns Scotus, and Univocity of Being
Available from the library catalog: https://marianunivindianapolis.on.worldcat.org/v2/oclc/1237694305 and Available from the Publisher: https://eerdmans.christianbook.com/five-models-of-scripture/mark-reasoner/9780802876829/pd/876829?product_redirect=1&Ntt=9780802876829&item_code=&ps_exit=RETURN|legacy&Ntk=keywords&event=ESRCG
Beschreibung:
A Christian never gains all that Scripture offers by reading it with just one approach. Yet too often this is attempted--whether through an academic obsession with the historical-critical method or through a consumerist approach that seeks only the motivation of the moment. Mark Reasoner broadens the options for scriptural engagement by describing five models of Scripture: documents, stories, prayers, laws, and oracles. To illustrate each, he uses examples from throughout the history of interpretation. While he concedes that certain books of the Bible will naturally lend themselves to particular models, Reasoner shows how an appreciation for all five will enrich one's scriptural insights while also bridging divides between the various branches of the Christian family. In addition to the five models, Reasoner surveys Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant constructions of the biblical canon and addresses specific issues relevant to their respective interpretations of Scripture, including scriptural metanarratives, the use of the Bible in Christian worship, and the principle of sola Scriptura. Through it all, Reasoner remains unequivocally focused on his goal: "to help readers grow in their love for Scripture in ways that will help them plant this love in those to whom they minister."
Erklärung der Rechte:
http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
Sprache:
English
Herausgeber:
William. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company
Identifikator:
ISBN: 9780802876829 and ISBN: 080287682X
Ressourcentyp:
Book
Stichwort:
Christian worship, Biblical Interpretation, and Scriptural engagement